Is It Better to Go to Trial or Take a Plea Deal in Florida?

One of the most critical decisions in any criminal case is whether to resolve the case through a plea agreement or to take it to trial. There’s no universal answer — it depends on the facts, the risks, the potential penalties, and your long-term goals.

At The Bonderud Law Firm, we help clients weigh the pros and cons of each path and build a strategy that protects their future. Here’s what you should know about choosing between trial and a plea in Florida.

Understanding the Plea Deal Option

A plea deal — also known as a plea bargain — is an agreement between the prosecution and defense. You plead guilty or no contest to some or all of the charges in exchange for:

• A reduced charge
• A lighter sentence
• Withholding of adjudication
• Probation instead of jail time
• Dismissal of other counts

Plea deals are the most common way criminal cases are resolved. They offer certainty — but not always justice.

When Plea Deals Make Sense

✅ You’re facing a strong case with serious penalties
✅ You want to avoid the risk and stress of trial
✅ The prosecution is offering a clearly favorable outcome
✅ You can avoid a felony conviction or jail
✅ You’re eligible for diversion or deferred prosecution

In these situations, a plea deal may be the most strategic move — but it should never be rushed or accepted blindly.

When Going to Trial May Be Better

✅ You maintain your innocence and want to fight the charges
✅ The evidence is weak or circumstantial
✅ You have strong legal defenses or constitutional violations
✅ A guilty plea would have devastating immigration, licensing, or employment consequences
✅ The plea offer is no better than what might happen at trial

Trial gives you the opportunity to have your case heard by a jury of your peers — and potentially walk away without a conviction.

Risks of Trial vs. Plea

• Trial: Greater risk of maximum penalties if convicted
• Plea: You give up your right to trial, appeal, and possibly a clean record

The key is knowing your case, your risk tolerance, and the long-term impact of each choice.

How a Lawyer Helps You Decide

At The Bonderud Law Firm, we don’t push plea deals just to clear a docket — and we don’t push trials unless there’s something to win. We carefully evaluate the facts, the law, and your personal situation to give you honest advice and aggressive representation.

If you’re facing criminal charges in Florida, contact us today to schedule a consultation and get clarity about your best path forward.